The SEPP Survival Guide: Top 4 Mistakes to Avoid When Setting Up SEPP IRA Distributions

The SEPP Survival Guide: Top 4 Mistakes to Avoid When Setting Up SEPP IRA Distributions

​

So, you're approaching the point where you can tap into your IRA funds before the traditional retirement age of 59 ½ without incurring that pesky 10% early withdrawal penalty. The magic key? Substantially Equal Periodic Payments, or SEPP, distributions under IRS Rule 72(t). This can be a lifeline for early retirees or those facing unexpected financial needs. Remember! A SEPP only avoids the 10% penalty, not ordinary income tax!

However, this seemingly straightforward path is riddled with potential pitfalls. Make a misstep, and you could find yourself facing that dreaded penalty after all. To help you navigate these tricky waters, let's review the top 4 mistakes I see early retirees make.

Mistake #1: Choosing the Wrong Calculation Method (and Not Understanding Its Implications)

The IRS offers three approved methods for calculating your SEPP distributions:

• The Required Minimum Distribution (RMD) Method: This method is the simplest initially, as it uses your life expectancy and account balance to determine the annual distribution. However, it generally results in the smallest initial payments.
• The Fixed Amortization Method: This method calculates a fixed annual payment based on your life expectancy, an interest rate (which cannot exceed 120% of the federal mid-term rate), and your account balance. The payments remain the same each year.
• The Fixed Annuitization Method: Similar to the amortization method, this also calculates a fixed annual payment but uses annuity factors instead of the federal mid-term rate.

The Mistake: Many individuals choose a method without fully understanding its long-term implications and the inflexibility it imposes. For example, opting for the fixed amortization or annuitization method might seem appealing for predictable income. However, these methods lock you into a specific payment amount for the duration of the SEPP period (generally five years or until age 59 ½, whichever is longer). If your financial needs change or your account balance fluctuates significantly, you're stuck with that initial calculation.

The Takeaway: Carefully consider your current and future financial needs and the potential volatility of your IRA balance. While the RMD method offers more flexibility as payments adjust annually with your balance, it might not provide the income you initially need. Seek professional advice to determine the most suitable method for your individual circumstances. Choosing the right calculation method should not be done in isolation. It needs to fit in with your overall financial plan. Other cash flow, income, assets, and investment risk should all be factors.

Mistake #2: Modifying Distributions Before the Mandatory Period Ends

This is arguably the most common and most costly mistake. Once you begin SEPP distributions, you are generally locked into a specific payment schedule and calculation method for the entire "restricted period." This period lasts for five full years after the first distribution and until you reach age 59 ½, whichever is later.

The Mistake: Life happens. You might experience a financial windfall, decide you no longer need the early distributions, or want to adjust the payment amount. Unfortunately, making any modification to your SEPP distributions before the restricted period ends – other than a one-time switch from the amortization or annuitization method to the RMD method – will trigger the dreaded 10% early withdrawal penalty on all the distributions you've received up to that point.

The Takeaway: Treat SEPP distributions as a serious commitment. Before initiating them, ensure you truly need the funds and are confident you can adhere to the chosen method and payment schedule for the entire restricted period. Consider all other available options before locking yourself into this inflexible arrangement. Don't just jump into a SEPP; look at all options in your financial plan. SEPP can be a great choice, but a financial plan really is needed to make sure it is a good choice.

Mistake #3: Not Documenting Everything Meticulously

Setting up and maintaining SEPP distributions requires meticulous record-keeping. The IRS needs to see that you are strictly adhering to the rules.

The Mistake: Failing to keep detailed records of your:

• Calculation method: Note exactly which method you used (RMD, amortization, or annuitization) and the factors involved (life expectancy, interest rate, annuity factor).
• Account balances: Record the balance used for the initial calculation and the year-end balances for each subsequent year.
• Distribution dates and amounts: Keep a clear log of every withdrawal.
• Any changes (if permitted): If you make the one-time switch from a fixed method to the RMD method, document the date and reason.

The Takeaway: Treat your SEPP distributions like an audit waiting to happen. Maintain thorough and organized records. If you used a financial advisor or software to set up the distributions, keep copies of their calculations and any related correspondence. This documentation will be crucial if the IRS ever questions your withdrawals.

Mistake #4: Failing to Segregate Assets into a Separate IRA for SEPP, Limiting Flexibility

A significant missed opportunity for many considering SEPP distributions is the failure to strategically separate the assets intended for early withdrawal into a distinct, newly established IRA account.

The Mistake: Instead of creating a dedicated IRA solely for the purpose of generating SEPP income, individuals often initiate the 72(t) distributions from one of their existing, larger IRA accounts. This ties their entire balance to the inflexible SEPP rules for the duration of the restricted period.

Why this limits flexibility:

• All Assets Become Subject to SEPP: When you take SEPP from a commingled account, the calculation is based on that entire balance. This means a larger portion of your retirement savings is locked into the distribution schedule.
• Loss of Access to Other Funds: If unexpected needs arise and you want to access funds beyond your SEPP distributions, doing so from the same account before the restricted period ends will likely trigger the penalty on all prior SEPP withdrawals.
• Complicated Management: Trying to mentally carve out a "SEPP portion" within a larger account can lead to confusion and potential errors.

The Takeaway: To maximize flexibility and control over your retirement assets, strongly consider transferring the specific amount you intend to use for SEPP distributions into a new, separate traditional IRA account. The SEPP calculations and withdrawals will then be isolated to this account, leaving your remaining IRA assets untouched and accessible (subject to standard withdrawal rules based on age) without jeopardizing your SEPP arrangement. This strategic separation allows you to meet your early income needs while preserving the flexibility of your broader retirement savings. For most clients, using the calculation method with the highest fixed distribution amount and then carving out the right amount to SEPP is the best way to go.

Final Thoughts:

SEPP IRA distributions can be a valuable tool for accessing retirement funds early, but they demand careful planning and strict adherence to the rules. By understanding and avoiding these top four mistakes, you can navigate this complex area successfully and avoid the costly 10% penalty. Always remember to consult with a qualified financial advisor or tax professional before setting up SEPP distributions to ensure you're making informed decisions that align with your individual financial situation and goals.

If you need help setting up a financial plan and a SEPP, click below to see if we are a good fit!

To health and wealth!

Mark Struthers, CFA, CFP®, CRC®, RMA®

For current clients looking for a meeting:

​